e-Negotiations of Contracts
A Half-Day
Tutorial
Willy Picard
This tutorial is focusing on technical
approaches to e-negotiations of contracts. The aim of this tutorial is to
introduce participants to the technologies associated with e-negotiations of
contracts as well as provide a brief overview of key research issues in this
new and fast growing area.
In the era of delocalization
and globalization of economy, companies need to negotiate at a global scale.
The high costs related to face-to-face meetings can be reduced by the use of
the Internet as a communication medium. New tools are, however, needed to
allow contractors, both from multinational enterprises and from SMEs, to
negotiate efficiently in this highly concurrent environment that Internet
is.
The detailed plan of the
tutorial is the following.
1.
Basic concepts
Multiple research areas
related to negotiations - e.g. economics, sociology, history, or psychology
- are briefly presented to give a complete overview of existing approaches
to negotiations. Concepts concerning both contracts and e-negotiations are
then defined, e.g. integrative/distributive negotiations,
single/multi-attribute contracts, Pareto-optimal results or the Nash
equilibrium.
2.
Contract e-Negotiation Taxonomy
A taxonomy of e-negotiation
approaches is presented that allows to classify existing approaches to
e-negotiations of contracts. Two criteria are used to define this taxonomy.
The first one is the number of negotiators involved in the negotiation,
while the second one is complexity of negotiated contracts, in terms of
number of attributes, qualitative or quantitative character of the
attributes, and existence or not of formal specification of semantics.
3.
Mass e-Negotiations of Simple Contracts
Mass e-negotiations of
simple contracts are negotiations in which the number of negotiators is high
and a few attributes of contracts - usually only the price - are negotiated.
Agent-based negotiation models are particularly well adapted to this kind of
negotiations. In these models, first, negotiators usually inform their
agents about their preferences concerning the output of the negotiation,
second, agents cooperate to find an optimal result for all negotiators.
Agent-based negotiation models are presented, as well as their limitations.
4.
Negotiation of Complex Contracts by Few Negotiators
In the case of complex
contracts - such as loan contracts - containing many attributes, both
quantitative and qualitative, potentially without any formally specified
semantics, agent-based negotiation models are not well adapted. The
complexity of contracts imposes the intervention of humans as the "thinking
unit" of the negotiation process. Negotiation Support Systems (NSS) have
been built to provide negotiators with communicating and decision-making
tools. Both aspects of negotiation support systems - communication and
decision-making - are presented and discussed.
5.
Mass e-Negotiation of Complex Contracts
When a high number of
negotiators are working on complex contracts, agent-based models are not a
solution, because of the lack of semantics attached to negotiated contracts.
Negotiation support systems are a viable solution under condition that they
provide negotiators with some synthetic views of the negotiations process.
The multi-facet analysis approach that allows negotiators to analyze various
aspects of a given negotiation process is presented and discussed in
details.
6.
Conclusions and Discussion
This tutorial is addressed both to the attendees having technical and
economical background in negotiations, as this tutorial shows the
relationships between economical environments and possible technical
solutions for e-negotiations. The target audience includes: